It's the kind of joint you'd expect to see in a mafia flick. Dark wood and burgundy accent the decor. A white baby grand sits in the lounge. Quiet diners dress tastefully with understated elegance. Stars and star-gazers perch at tables. But remember--autograph seekers have no place at Donatello, and the staff here will tell you as much.

Start your meal with a little smoked salmon, carpaccio or some zuppa campagnola--a chicken broth with spinach, cheese and whisked egg. Then move on to one of the Don's many pasta dishes, like the tortellini in double cream sauce. And after all that, if you're up to it, order an entree. Chicken fans will take to the eggplant and mozzarella version, while beef lovers will enjoy the filet with goose pate.